New
adventures in Irish prehistory
Irish Prehistory: a social perspective
by Gabriel Cooney and Eoin Grogan (Wordwell. 1999 2nd edition.)
Landscapes of Neolithic Ireland by Gabriel Cooney (Routledge.
2000.)
Excavations at Ferriter's Cove, 1983-95: last foragers, first farmers
in the Dingle Peninsula, by Peter C. Woodman, Elizabeth Anderson
and Nyree Finlay (Wordwell. 1999.)
New Agendas in Irish Prehistory: papers in commemoration of Liz Anderson
edited by Angela Desmond, Gina Johnson, Margaret McCarthy, John Sheehan
and Elizabeth Shee-Twohig (Wordwell. 1999)
The last decade or so has been a time of great expansion in Irish archaeology.
The booming economy of the south in particular has led to a tremendous
upsurge in development and infrastructure renewal schemes which have
in turn led to a substantial increase in the number and scale of developer-funded
excavations. The results of this work inevitably challenge many long-held
assumptions about Ireland's prehistoric past and force us to re-examine
established frameworks of thought. The four volumes reviewed here each
attempt to address aspects of this brave new world of Irish prehistory.
Irish prehistory: a social perspective, by Gabriel Cooney and
Eoin Grogan, is not a new publication, but rather an interim update
of their 1994 volume in advance of a planned 2nd edition. The publication
of this book first time around may be seen in retrospect to mark something
of a watershed in the study of Irish prehistory, ushering in a period
of greater reflection and deepening debate. The book is by no means
a comprehensive introduction to Irish prehistory (which is well served
by a series of textbooks, most recently Waddell 1998), but rather a
commentary on the social dimensions of otherwise familiar evidence.
As such it draws heavily on a series of broadly post-processual perspectives
which had previously been little explored in an Irish context.
This updated version comprises the unamended text of the original,
with the addition of a new 17 page chapter ('New perspectives') in which
the authors survey the mass of new data and research which has accumulated
since the book was first published. It says much for the speed of current
developments in Irish archaeology that such an exercise was felt necessary
after only five years, but Cooney and Grogan's brief re- survey demonstrates
how much important new work is taking place. For example, the secure
dating of the Céide Fields, Co. Mayo, to 3700-3200 cal BC, and
the recent work at Roughan Hill, Co. Clare, have demonstrated beyond
reasonable doubt the existence of settled and bounded Neolithic landscapes
(at least in parts of Ireland) in contrast to the dominant perceptions
in much of Britain.
Cooney and Grogan also restate and expand upon some of their
original themes, for example the persistence of local and regional identities
and social practices across conventional period boundaries, and the
socialisation of particular landscapes. Long-lived practices such as
hoarding and the special attention accorded to rivers and other watery
places are also viewed as part of the way in which people embedded their
social lives within specific landscapes and localities. Thus the strong
regionality apparently marked by the construction of formal linear boundaries
and routeways in the Later Bronze Age and Iron Age may reflect much
deeper bonds between people and place stretching back into early prehistory.
Overall, this a useful if rather limited update, of what has become
an essential book for anyone with a serious interest in Irish prehistory.
The full 2nd edition is eagerly anticipated.
Gabriel Cooney's Landscapes of Neolithic Ireland reprises many
of the themes set out in Irish prehistory: a social perspective, but
here he has more space to develop his ideas within a tighter chronological
framework. Again this is not straightforward textbook, and a basic familiarity
with the material is more or less assumed. Instead Cooney structures
his discussion of the various categories of Neolithic material expression,
such as houses, tombs, enclosures, sacred landscapes, stone axes, pottery
etc, around a series of unifying themes. He is explicit in attempting
to redress the perceived imbalance of descriptive over interpretative
approaches which has characterised much previous writing on the Irish
Neolithic.
Familiar from his earlier book are Cooney's concerns with the
socialisation of the landscape and the importance of seeing regional
variation as the expression of distinct identities (as opposed to obstinate
divergence from notional 'island-wide norms'). In this study, Cooney
is more explicit in his consideration of the multiple layers of time
with which archaeologists deal. Acknowledging a debt to the annaliste
school, and Braudel in particular, he considers the interplay of human
actions and social change at a range of temporal scales, from the human
lifetime, through the 'public' or social time of monument building,
oral tradition and ritual observance, through to the longue durée
of conventional archaeological periodisation.
In his last chapter Cooney incorporates a series of fictionalised
narratives to express more fully how he sees the long term development
of Neolithic landscapes (specifically the Brú na Bóinne
complex). These will not be to everyone's taste in the often conservative
world of Irish archaeology, but they do provide a concise encapsulation
of much of the more straightforwardly academic argument of previous
chapters. In many ways this book represents a realisation of the potential
flagged up in Cooney's earlier work. It is a stimulating and absorbing
read, though as Cooney admits, by no means the last word on the Irish
Neolithic.
While Gabriel Cooney distils a wealth of evidence from across
the island, Excavations at Ferriter's Cove 1983-95, by Peter Woodman,
Liz Anderson and Nyree Finlay, focuses on a single corner of Co. Kerry.
South-west Ireland has often been marginalised in accounts of early
Irish prehistory, regarded as almost an 'empty landscape' prior to the
Bronze Age. The work reported here explodes that particular myth and
will have ramifications for the way we look at the Irish Mesolithic
as a whole and the Mesolithic-Neolithic transition in particular.
Work at Ferriter's Cove was triggered by the discovery, by a
local amateur archaeologist, of part of a distinctive (rather ironically)
Neolithic plano-convex knife associated with a series of eroding coastal
deposits. Woodman and his team subsequently initiated excavations which
eventually encompassed around 400m2 of a Later Mesolithic land surface
fortuitously protected from later disturbance by a deep blanket of sand.
These excavations revealed innumerable, individually slight traces of
human occupation which combined to suggest repeated human activity over
a lengthy period, probably from around 4600-4000 cal BC. The substantial
lithic assemblage seemed also to indicate the on-site production of
tool types similar to those of the Later Mesolithic elsewhere in Ireland,
notably the north-east, but constrained by the range of intractable
raw materials, such as rhyolites, sandstones and siltstones.
One of the most significant findings, however, was the presence
in the faunal assemblage of cattle bones dating to perhaps as early
as 4500 cal BC. This is well before the appearance of anything resembling
a Neolithic 'cultural package' in Ireland, around 4000 cal BC, and forces
us to examine the possibility of the introduction of domesticated animals
to Ireland in a Mesolithic context.
The fourth volume, New Agendas in Irish prehistory represents
the proceedings of a conference held in Cork in 1999 in memory of Liz
Anderson (co-author of the Ferriter's Cove monograph). It comprises
fifteen essays on various aspects of Irish prehistory which aim to 'identify
and review a range of current problems in Irish prehistory'. Peter Woodman's
opening contribution tackles the problem of 'new agendas' head on, by
identifying what he sees as some of the most deep-rooted and insidious
problems affecting the way Irish prehistory is studied. These include
a rather too deferential attitude to the 'canon' of traditional thought
which Woodman sees as hampering progress across the discipline. Like
Cooney and Grogan, Woodman cites the problems of artificial period boundaries
and monument/artefacts classifications which can prevent the identification
of long-term processes and create circularity of argument. Similarly,
the tendency to frame our questions in a rather narrow way (for example,
to consider the appearance of La Tène art in terms of the 'origins
of the Irish') leads to a certain insularity of approach. Instead Woodman
suggests that we should be identifying those areas where the rich Irish
data-sets can enable us to make contributions to archaeological problems
on a European scale. Woodman also sees the tradition of typologically-driven
research as responsible for the continued down-playing of those periods
which lack characteristic suites of artefactual material (most critically
perhaps the Later Mesolithic and Iron Age).
Several other contributions, such as those by Monk, Kimbal and
Shee-Twohig, provide useful summaries of the state of play in various
aspects of Irish prehistory, especially the Later Mesolithic and Neolithic.
Others draw upon the mass of emerging data from recent rescue excavation
to elucidate particular issues, e.g. Martin Doody's analysis of the
evidence for Bronze Age houses. Elsewhere Maher and Sheehan present
a comparative analysis of Dowris period and Viking hoards which raises
some useful issues regarding the different assumptions applied to essentially
similar data-sets by workers in different periods. In doing so they
also provide a small but telling example of the potential benefits of
breaking free from traditional period specialisation.
Of particular interest to this reviewer is Barra Ó Donnabháin's
contribution on the thorny question of the Irish Iron Age. Much more
than in Britain, the Irish Iron Age has long been dominated by questions
of Celticity, specifically the 'coming of the Irish', and it is in this
period that the inter-twining of contemporary politics and archaeological
interpretation is at its most marked. The Celts have been used, for
example, both to bolster colonial attitudes (Celts as incoming 'cultural
improvers') and to proclaim an Irish identity in opposition to English
colonialism (Celts as the original 'Irish'). Ó Donnabháin
reviews the 'Celtic paradigm' in Ireland in the light of the recent
vigorous debates over the existence and utility of the 'ancient Celts'
(e.g. Megaw and Megaw 1996; James 1999). In his view, it is only with
the establishment of alternatives to this Celtic paradigm that progress
can be made in our understandings of this most elusive slice of Ireland's
prehistory.
Questions of regionality are much to the fore throughout the
volume, most notably in the contributions by Gabriel Cooney and Sinead
McCartan, for the Neolithic and Mesolithic respectively. Both question
the tendency to project modern perceptions of regionality, whether based
on modern socio-political boundaries or perceived environmental 'zones',
onto the prehistoric past. The striking divergence in Later Mesolithic
chipped stone traditions either side of the North Channel, for example,
seems to defy both the close geographical links and the marked cultural
contacts of later times, such as the Neolithic or Early Historic periods.
The volume closes with a general review by John Coles, which
echoes some of those issues raised by Woodman. In particular Coles laments
the ways in which Ireland is often marginalised in wider accounts of
European prehistory, reduced to a check-list of key sites, 'Mount Sandel,
Newgrange and Knowth'. In Coles' view, the tendency to treat Irish prehistory
as a purely Irish 'story' has been unhelpful in drawing out the wider
potential of Ireland as a virtual island laboratory for the study of
some of the key cultural transformations in Europe's prehistoric past.
The 'agendas' dealt with in this volume are predominantly academic
ones, and there is relatively little coverage of issues relating to
the more 'practical' agendas of data acquisition, management and dissemination.
The exceptions are Denis Power's update on the work of the Archaeological
Survey of Ireland and Caroline Wickham-Jones' discussion of her experiences
of publishing on the Web. Given the publication crisis in Irish archaeology,
which is perhaps the single most pressing issue facing the discipline
(O'Sullivan 2001), this area might have been given rather more coverage.
As John Coles points out, it is wonderful to see so much exciting new
work unfold in the pages of Archaeology Ireland, but how many of these
projects ever see anything approaching full publication? It might also
have been useful to have had a rather wider overview of palaeoenvironmental
issues, which surely must represent one of the most central areas of
future research. There is nonetheless a good deal of important work
here which will certainly push the debate further forwards.
The publication of all four volumes demonstrates the flourishing
state of Irish prehistory at the transition from the 20th to the 21st
century. The last ten years have seen the appearance of major works
of syntheses, notably Waddell's Prehistoric Archaeology of Ireland (1998),
the realisation of internationally significant research programmes initiated
through the Discovery Programme (e.g. Newman 1997, O'Sullivan 1998),
publication projects targeting major unpublished excavations, such as
Lynn's completion of Waterman's work at Navan (Waterman 1997), and the
consolidation of Archaeology Ireland as a vehicle for the swift dissemination
of the preliminary results of fieldwork. There is more excavation and
survey being carried out now than ever before. The challenge for the
next ten years is to design and build the conceptual, academic and management
frameworks with which to accommodate the results.
References
James, S. 1999. The Atlantic Celts: ancient
people or modern invention? London: British Museum.
Megaw, J. V. S. and Megaw, M. R. 1996. Ancient Celts and modern ethnicity.
Antiquity LXX, 175-81.
Newman, C. 1997. Tara: an archaeological survey (Discovery Programme
Monograph 2). Dublin: Royal Irish Academy/Discovery Programme.
O'Sullivan, A. 1997. The archaeology of lake settlement in Ireland (Discovery
Programme Monograph 4). Dublin: Royal Irish Academy/Discovery Programme.
O'Sullivan, J. 2001. Biscuits, bread and fishes - data famine in times
of plenty. Archaeology Ireland 58, 33-4.
Waddell, J. 1998. The prehistoric archaeology of Ireland. Galway: University
of Galway.
Waterman, D. 1997. Excavations at Navan fort 1961-71 (Northern Ireland
Archaeological Monographs No. 3). Belfast: The Stationery Office.
Ian Armit
Queen's University Belfast.
Review Submitted: July 2002
The views expressed in this review are not necessarily
those of the Society or the Reviews Editor.
|